SoftwarePlus.ai

All programs › BMPFast › Questions answered

The treatment depth of a filter below a routed wet pond

Catchment 1's wet pond discharges to Catchment 2's wet pond, which has filter media. How BMPFast Plus works out the filter's treatment depth, each removal efficiency and the loads at the outlet, with the program's own numbers.

1The question

Treatment depth calculation: for a filter media in Catchment 2 (where Catchment 1 has a wet detention pond discharging into Catchment 2's wet pond), how should the treatment depth be calculated? Do we divide the treatment volume in the second pond by the combined contributing areas of Catchments 1 and 2, or by Catchment 2 only?

Short answer: by Catchment 2 only. In BMPFast Plus the filter's treatment depth is the volume it treats spread over its own catchment: here 1.05 ac-ft × 12 ÷ 25.13 ac = 0.501 in. The program does not divide by the areas of Catchments 1 and 2 together.

Catchment 1 is accounted for another way. Catchment 2's pond and filter are calculated on Catchment 2, which gives a removal in percent. The routing then applies that percentage to all the load reaching Catchment 2: its own runoff plus what Catchment 1's pond discharges.

2The example

Catchments 1 and 2 are the first two catchments of the wet-detention-in-series example in the BMPTrains 2020 manual (pages 190–196). Each has a wet pond with a littoral zone. For this question, Catchment 2's pond also sends its treatment volume through filter media (B&G CTS12). In BMPFast Plus that is a Surface Discharge Filter after the pond, joined in a BMPs in Series: wet pond 2, then the filter.

InputCatchment 1Catchment 2
Project (General Site Information)
Meteorological zone · mean annual rainfallFlorida Zone 4 · 52 in
Type of analysisAll sites non-exempted (required removal: N 55 %, P 80 %)
Catchment (post-development)
Area (ac)20.7525.13
Non-DCIA curve number76.1276.12
DCIA (%)17.917.8
Annual runoff (ac-ft/yr)20.07723.645
Nitrogen load (kg/yr)44.95450.000
Phosphorus load (kg/yr)11.21411.866
Treatment
Wet pond: permanent pool volume (ac-ft)1.001.25
Wet pond: littoral zoneYes (credit 10 %)Yes (credit 10 %)
Filter: media mix—B&G CTS12 (N 60 %, P 90 %)
Filter: treatment volume through the media (ac-ft)—1.05
Treatment used in the routingWet pond 1BMPs in Series: wet pond 2, then the filter
Drains toCatchment 2Outlet

The runoff and loads are the catchments' land uses worked out by the program; they are inputs here so the steps below can start from them.

3The calculation, step by step

These are the steps BMPFast Plus takes, in its order, with the values it calculates (rounded for reading).

  1. Catchment 1's wet pond. Nothing drains to Catchment 1, so its pond treats only its own runoff. The average residence time is the permanent pool over the annual runoff:

    Residence time = 1.00 ac-ft ÷ 20.077 ac-ft/yr × 365 = 18.18 days N removal = 43.75 × 18.18 ÷ (4.38 + 18.18) = 35.26 %; + 10 % littoral credit = 45.26 % P removal = 40.13 + 6.372 ln(18.18) + 0.213 [ln(18.18)]² = 60.40 %; + 10 % = 70.40 % N leaving = 44.954 × (1 − 0.4526) = 24.609 kg/yr P leaving = 11.214 × (1 − 0.7040) = 3.319 kg/yr

    A wet pond removes no water: all 20.077 ac-ft/yr goes on to Catchment 2. The 10 % is BMPFast Plus's littoral zone credit, added for a pond with a littoral zone (BMPFast v1 instead takes 90 % of the removal for a pond without one).

  2. The filter's treatment depth: over Catchment 2. The depth is the inches of Catchment 2's runoff the filter treats. That gives the filter's capture, read from the Zone 4 retention tables at Catchment 2's non-DCIA curve number and DCIA:

    Treatment depth = 1.05 ac-ft × 12 in/ft ÷ 25.13 ac = 0.501 in Capture = retention tables (Zone 4, CN 76.12, DCIA 17.8 %) at 0.501 in = 65.40 % (the tables give 65.35 % at 0.50 in and 74.14 % at 0.75 in) Filter N removal = 65.40 % × 60 % = 39.24 % Filter P removal = 65.40 % × 90 % = 58.86 %

    On the filter's Entry tab, Treatment depth is typed in inches "over the catchment": type 0.50 (the project file holds 0.501). The retention curves show these tables.

  3. Catchment 2's wet pond. As part of Catchment 2's BMPs in Series, the pond is calculated on Catchment 2's own runoff:

    Residence time = 1.25 ac-ft ÷ 23.645 ac-ft/yr × 365 = 19.30 days N removal = 43.75 × 19.30 ÷ (4.38 + 19.30) = 35.66 %; + 10 % = 45.66 % P removal = 40.13 + 6.372 ln(19.30) + 0.213 [ln(19.30)]² = 60.86 %; + 10 % = 70.86 %
  4. Catchment 2's series: the pond, then the filter. A wet pond followed by a filter is calculated one BMP at a time, the load leaving the pond going into the filter (Applicant's Handbook Vol. I, Equation 9-5, the treatment train):

    N: 50.000 × (1 − 0.4566) = 27.172 → 27.172 × (1 − 0.3924) = 16.509 kg/yr P: 11.866 × (1 − 0.7086) = 3.458 → 3.458 × (1 − 0.5886) = 1.423 kg/yr Series removal N = (50.000 − 16.509) ÷ 50.000 = 66.98 % P = (11.866 − 1.423) ÷ 11.866 = 88.01 % the same as 1 − (1 − 0.4566)(1 − 0.3924) = 66.98 % and 1 − (1 − 0.7086)(1 − 0.5886) = 88.01 %
  5. The routing at Catchment 2. What reaches Catchment 2 is its own load plus Catchment 1's discharge. The series removal from step 4 is applied to all of it:

    N in = 50.000 + 24.609 = 74.609 kg/yr N out = 74.609 × (1 − 0.6698) = 24.635 kg/yr P in = 11.866 + 3.319 = 15.185 kg/yr P out = 15.185 × (1 − 0.8801) = 1.821 kg/yr Water: 23.645 + 20.077 = 43.721 ac-ft/yr in, and all of it out (neither a pond nor a filter removes water)
  6. At the outlet. The site's removal compares the loads leaving the site with the loads both catchments make:

    N: catchments 44.954 + 50.000 = 94.954 kg/yr; leaving 24.635 → removal (94.954 − 24.635) ÷ 94.954 = 74.06 % P: catchments 11.214 + 11.866 = 23.080 kg/yr; leaving 1.821 → removal (23.080 − 1.821) ÷ 23.080 = 92.11 %

    Required: N 55 %, P 80 %. Met.

NodeTreatmentOwn load N / P (kg/yr)From upstream N / PRemoval N / PLeaving N / P (kg/yr)
Catchment 1Wet pond 144.954 / 11.2140 / 045.26 % / 70.40 %24.609 / 3.319
Catchment 2Wet pond 2 → filter50.000 / 11.86624.609 / 3.31966.98 % / 88.01 %24.635 / 1.821
Outlet94.954 / 23.08074.06 % / 92.11 %24.635 / 1.821

4Why Catchment 2 only

  • A filter's removal comes from its treatment depth over its own catchment. The capture is read from the retention tables with Catchment 2's curve number and DCIA, so the depth has to be on the same basis: inches of Catchment 2's runoff.
  • Catchment 1's water is not left out. Step 5 applies Catchment 2's removal to Catchment 1's discharge as well. Dividing the volume by both areas as well would count Catchment 1 a second time.
  • Which treatments the routing re-calculates. When a catchment's treatment is a single retention basin or a single wet pond, the routing re-calculates it with what arrives from upstream: a basin's volume over all the area draining to it, a pond's residence time with all the runoff reaching it. A BMPs in Series, like this pond and filter, is not re-calculated: it keeps the removal it has on Catchment 2 (steps 3 and 4).

5For comparison: dividing by both catchments

This is not what BMPFast Plus does. It shows how much the answer to the question changes the result: the same project, with the filter's treatment depth typed as the volume over Catchments 1 and 2 together.

Over Catchment 2 (BMPFast Plus)Over Catchments 1 + 2
Treatment depth1.05 × 12 ÷ 25.13 = 0.501 in1.05 × 12 ÷ 45.88 = 0.275 in
Filter capture65.40 %51.30 %
Filter removal N / P39.24 % / 58.86 %30.78 % / 46.17 %
Catchment 2 series removal N / P66.98 % / 88.01 %62.38 % / 84.31 %
Leaving the site N / P (kg/yr)24.635 / 1.82128.065 / 2.382
Site removal N / P74.06 % / 92.11 %70.44 % / 89.68 %

6Try it, and read more

Calculated with the calculation code of BMPFast Plus 2.0.4 (BMPFast version 2), November 2, 2026. The saved project, opened again and calculated, gives the numbers on this page. Questions: info@bmpfast.com.