SoftwarePlus.ai

All programs › BMPFast › Help

Comparison of Methods for Calculating Filters in Series

A copy of the help on bmpfast.com (last changed there 2026-10-21; copied here 2026-10-21). These pages describe the windows of BMPFast (version 1). BMPFast 2 uses the same methods; its numbered buttons are the tree on the left: General Site Information, then Catchments with their Treatments, Catchment Routings and Calculators.

A Surface Discharge Filter reads its capture from the retention curves at its Treatment Depth and removes the media’s share of the water it captures: removal = capture × media reduction (Surface Discharge Filter, Media Methodology). When two filters are placed one after the other, in one catchment (BMPs in Series) or in two catchments routed one into the other (Routing), there are two ways to combine them. This page calculates both and compares them.

Method 1: each filter on its own, routed to the next

Each filter is calculated on its own. The first removes its share of the load; what it lets through goes to the second, which removes its share of that. This is BMPFast’s default.

Applicant’s Handbook reference

Section 9.5.1 Treatment Train Nutrient Reduction (Equation 9-5): Method 1 is Equation 9-5: 1 − [(1 − Eff1) × (1 − Eff2)], each filter acting independently on what the one before it lets through.

Appendix O, Detention with Engineered Media and Filtration: gives “Treatment efficiency for Detention Pond with Filtration = (Detention efficiency for Volume of the water Detained in the system) + (Volume of water filtered and not detained * Treatment Efficiency of Media)”; each filter’s removal (capture × media reduction) is BMPFast’s reading of the filtered term.

Removal of filter i (%) = capture at its Treatment Depth (retention curves) × media reduction / 100
Removal of the series (%) = 100 × [1 − (1 − removal 1 / 100) × (1 − removal 2 / 100)]

Method 2: equivalent Treatment Depths added

Each filter’s removal is turned into an equivalent Treatment Depth: the depth at which the retention curves give that removal as capture. The equivalent depths are added, and the curves are read at the sum. This is how retention BMPs in series are combined (the Equivalent Treatment Depth of BMPs in Series).

Applicant’s Handbook reference

Appendix O, Dry Retention Systems: removal is read from the tables at the retention depth in inches over the catchment area; the handbook does not describe equivalent treatment depths for filters, or adding them. Method 2 is a method proposed for BMPFast, not a handbook method.

Source reference

A method allowed in BMPFast and BMPFast 2 (Ron Eaglin, 2026-10-19 and 2026-10-20): adding equivalent Treatment Depths extends BMPFast’s rule for retention BMPs in series (BMP Trains 2020 User Manual, Stormwater Management Academy, University of Central Florida, December 2021 (stars.library.ucf.edu/bmptrains/25)) to filters; it is not in the handbook or the BMPTrains model. Method 1 is BMPFast’s default.

Equivalent Treatment Depth of filter i (in) = the depth where the retention curves give its removal
Removal of the series (%) = retention curves at (equivalent depth 1 + equivalent depth 2)
(N and P separately: the media reduce N and P differently, so each has its own equivalent depths)

A second reading of “equivalent Treatment Depth” is the filter’s Treatment Depth times its media reduction (2b in the table below). It is shown for comparison only.

Worked example, step by step

Two Surface Discharge Filters with B&G CTS12 media (N reduction 60 %, P reduction 90 %) in a 12.00 ac catchment, one after the other: all the water that enters the first goes on to the second. The two therefore treat the same water from the same 12.00 ac, and have the same Treatment Volume, 0.500 ac-ft, and the same Treatment Depth. The catchment has a Non-DCIA Curve Number of 70 and DCIA of 24.33 % in Florida Zone 2; the retention curves for it are the program’s, read every 0.005 in. For illustration, 10.000 kg/yr of nitrogen and 2.000 kg/yr of phosphorus reach the first filter (the percentages do not depend on the load). Each value is rounded as it is calculated (percentages to 0.1, loads to 0.001 kg/yr, depths to 0.001 in), so every line can be checked by hand.

Both methods: the Treatment Depth and capture of each filter

Both methods start from the filters’ Treatment Volumes. A filter’s Treatment Depth is its Treatment Volume spread over the area draining to it, in inches. All the water entering filter 1 goes to filter 2, so both filters have the same area draining to them and the same Treatment Volume, and so the same Treatment Depth. The Treatment Volumes are the same in both methods, so the Treatment Depths are the same, and so are the captures read at them; the methods differ only in how the two filters’ removals are combined (the steps after these). The capture is the share of the runoff a filter treats: the retention curves at its Treatment Depth, the same for nitrogen and phosphorus.

Treatment Depth (in) = 12 (in/ft) × Treatment Volume (ac-ft) / area draining to the filter (ac)
StepWhat is calculatedValue
ATreatment Depth of filter 112 × 0.500 / 12.00 = 0.500 in
BTreatment Depth of filter 212 × 0.500 / 12.00 = 0.500 in
CCapture of filter 1 at its Treatment Depth (step A)curves at 0.500 in = 75.31 %, so 75.3 %
DCapture of filter 2 at its Treatment Depth (step B)curves at 0.500 in = 75.31 %, so 75.3 %

Method 1: each filter on its own, routed to the next

StepWhat is calculatedNitrogenPhosphorus
1Load reaching filter 110.000 kg/yr2.000 kg/yr
2Removal of filter 1 = capture (step C) × media reduction / 10075.3 × 60 / 100 = 45.2 %75.3 × 90 / 100 = 67.8 %
3Load removed by filter 110.000 × 45.2 / 100 = 4.520 kg/yr2.000 × 67.8 / 100 = 1.356 kg/yr
4Load leaving filter 1 = load reaching filter 210.000 − 4.520 = 5.480 kg/yr2.000 − 1.356 = 0.644 kg/yr
5Removal of filter 2 = capture (step D) × media reduction / 10075.3 × 60 / 100 = 45.2 %75.3 × 90 / 100 = 67.8 %
6Load removed by filter 25.480 × 45.2 / 100 = 2.477 kg/yr0.644 × 67.8 / 100 = 0.437 kg/yr
7Load leaving filter 2 (leaving the series)5.480 − 2.477 = 3.003 kg/yr0.644 − 0.437 = 0.207 kg/yr
8Removal of the series100 × (10.000 − 3.003) / 10.000 = 70.0 %100 × (2.000 − 0.207) / 2.000 = 89.6 %

Step 8 is the same as 100 × [1 − (1 − removal 1 / 100) × (1 − removal 2 / 100)], the formula above.

Method 2: equivalent Treatment Depths added

StepWhat is calculatedNitrogenPhosphorus
1Removal of filter 1 = capture (step C) × media reduction / 10075.3 × 60 / 100 = 45.2 %75.3 × 90 / 100 = 67.8 %
2Equivalent Treatment Depth of filter 1: the depth where the retention curves give that removalthe curves give 45.2 % between 0.195 in (44.62 %) and 0.200 in (45.76 %): 0.195 + (0.200 − 0.195) × (45.2 − 44.62) / (45.76 − 44.62) = 0.198 inthe curves give 67.8 % between 0.395 in (67.70 %) and 0.400 in (68.07 %): 0.395 + (0.400 − 0.395) × (67.8 − 67.70) / (68.07 − 67.70) = 0.396 in
3Removal of filter 2 = capture (step D) × media reduction / 10075.3 × 60 / 100 = 45.2 %75.3 × 90 / 100 = 67.8 %
4Equivalent Treatment Depth of filter 2the curves give 45.2 % between 0.195 in (44.62 %) and 0.200 in (45.76 %): 0.195 + (0.200 − 0.195) × (45.2 − 44.62) / (45.76 − 44.62) = 0.198 inthe curves give 67.8 % between 0.395 in (67.70 %) and 0.400 in (68.07 %): 0.395 + (0.400 − 0.395) × (67.8 − 67.70) / (68.07 − 67.70) = 0.396 in
5Equivalent Treatment Depth of the series = the sum0.198 + 0.198 = 0.396 in0.396 + 0.396 = 0.792 in
6Removal of the series: the retention curves at the sumcurves between 0.395 in (67.70 %) and 0.400 in (68.07 %): 67.70 + (68.07 − 67.70) × (0.396 − 0.395) / (0.400 − 0.395) = 67.8 %curves between 0.790 in (84.00 %) and 0.795 in (84.10 %): 84.00 + (84.10 − 84.00) × (0.792 − 0.790) / (0.795 − 0.790) = 84.0 %
7Load leaving the series10.000 × (1 − 67.8 / 100) = 3.220 kg/yr2.000 × (1 − 84.0 / 100) = 0.320 kg/yr

Method 2b: Treatment Depth × media reduction, added

For comparison only: here the equivalent Treatment Depth is the filter’s Treatment Depth (steps A and B) times its media reduction.

StepWhat is calculatedNitrogenPhosphorus
1Equivalent Treatment Depth of filter 1 = Treatment Depth × media reduction / 1000.500 × 60 / 100 = 0.300 in0.500 × 90 / 100 = 0.450 in
2Equivalent Treatment Depth of filter 20.500 × 60 / 100 = 0.300 in0.500 × 90 / 100 = 0.450 in
3Sum0.300 + 0.300 = 0.600 in0.450 + 0.450 = 0.900 in
4Removal of the series: the retention curves at the sumcurves at 0.600 in = 78.48 %, so 78.5 %curves at 0.900 in = 86.10 %, so 86.1 %
5Load leaving the series10.000 × (1 − 78.5 / 100) = 2.150 kg/yr2.000 × (1 − 86.1 / 100) = 0.278 kg/yr

The results side by side

Method 1: removal (load leaving)Method 22bMethod 2 − Method 1 (points)
Nitrogen70.0 % (3.003 kg/yr)67.8 % (3.220 kg/yr)78.5 % (2.150 kg/yr)-2.2
Phosphorus89.6 % (0.207 kg/yr)84.0 % (0.320 kg/yr)86.1 % (0.278 kg/yr)-5.6

The two methods compared

Treatment Depths (in)MediaEach filter alone (%)Method 1 (%)Equivalent depths (in)Method 2 (%)2b (%)Method 2 − Method 1
0.5 + 0.5B&G CTS12N45.2 / 45.270.00.20 + 0.2067.778.5-2.3
0.5 + 0.5B&G CTS12P67.8 / 67.889.60.40 + 0.4084.086.1-5.6
0.25 + 0.25B&G CTS12N34.3 / 34.356.90.15 + 0.1560.860.8+4.0
0.25 + 0.25B&G CTS12P51.5 / 51.576.50.23 + 0.2371.771.7-4.8
1.0 + 1.0B&G CTS12N52.8 / 52.877.70.23 + 0.2372.590.4-5.2
1.0 + 1.0B&G CTS12P79.2 / 79.295.70.62 + 0.6290.994.8-4.7
0.5 + 0.5B&G ECT MixesN33.9 / 33.956.30.15 + 0.1560.571.7+4.3
0.5 + 0.5B&G ECT MixesP33.9 / 33.956.30.15 + 0.1560.571.7+4.3
Two surface filters in series: nitrogen removal by each method, against the Treatment Depth of each filter (B&G CTS12)
Two surface filters in series: nitrogen removal by each method, against the Treatment Depth of each filter (B&G CTS12)

What the comparison shows. Neither method always gives more. Method 2 gives more removal when each filter removes little (shallow filters, or media that remove little), and Method 1 gives more when each filter removes a lot. The reason is the shape of the retention curves: they rise steeply at small depths and flatten towards 4 in. Adding two small equivalent depths moves up the steep part, which raises the removal more than multiplying the two removals; adding two large ones lands on the flat part, which raises it less. For two equal filters the methods cross at a Treatment Depth of 0.40 in for nitrogen and 0.20 in for phosphorus with B&G CTS12, and 1.22 in with B&G ECT.

Method 1 treats the second filter as if the water reaching it were ordinary runoff. It is what the first filter let through: the runoff it did not capture, mostly from the larger storms, plus the filtered water. Method 2 treats the two filters as one larger storage, as BMPFast does for retention BMPs in series, and so assumes the second filter’s storage adds to the first’s.

Decided (Ron Eaglin, 2026-10-19): both methods are allowed. BMPFast 2 offers them as a choice, Surface discharge filters in series: on a BMPs in Series’ Entry tab (for the filters from BMP 1 on), and on a Catchment Routing’s Entry tab (for catchments one after another whose treatments are all filters). Handbook equation is Method 1, the default; Equivalent treatment depth is Method 2. BMPFast (v1) offers the same choice for catchments routed one into another whose BMPs are all Surface Discharge Filters: Surface Discharge Filters (Filtration) in series on the Catchment Configuration window, under the diagram, shown when one filter catchment drains to another (Ron Eaglin, 2026-10-20). A v1 BMPs in Series cannot hold two filters (a catchment has one of each BMP), so the choice does not apply there. Method 2b above is shown for comparison only and is not offered. Method 2 is not in the handbook: say which method you used in your submittal.

Method 2 in a routing. When filters are in different catchments, each filter’s equivalent Treatment Depth is read on its own catchment’s retention curves (its Non-DCIA Curve Number and DCIA), the depths are added along the run of catchments, and the removal is the curves at the sum with the area-weighted Non-DCIA Curve Number and DCIA of those catchments, applied to all the load that has entered the run. It is used only where the catchments follow one another with no other water joining them and every treatment is a filter; elsewhere each filter is calculated on its own. The routing’s Entry tab (in v1, the line under the choice on the Catchment Configuration) says where it was used, and the Flow Balance report shows each system. A filter removes no runoff volume, so all the runoff goes on.

Sample problems

Worked problems solved in BMPFast, each with every input, the steps with screen captures, the program’s results, a hand check and the project file to download. Captures are for demonstration only. All of them: BMPFast sample problems.

Two different media, and a third method. Comparison of Methods for Filter Media in Series calculates Filter A (ICS) then Filter B (B&G CTS24), 4 in each, in a 12 ac Highway catchment by Methods 1 and 2 of this page, step by step, and by a third method, Specific Yield / Specific Retention, in which only the water that drains out of Filter A goes to Filter B.

Help home · List of every help page · This page on bmpfast.com · Sample problems